Arbitration Case Note: The Federal Court of Australia again reinforces Australia as an arbitration friendly jurisdiction.

WDR Delaware Corporation v Hydrox Holdings Pty Ltd 

Background

WDR, a wholly owned subsidiary of Lowes, a US-based home improvement company, entered into a joint venture agreement with Woolworths, an Australian-based retail company, to open hardware and home improvement stores in Australia and New Zealand. The joint venture agreement spawned Hydrox Holdings Pty Ltd, a registered Australian company. Woolworths owned two thirds of the shares in Hydrox and Lowes (through WDR) owned the other third. Hydrox has always operated at a loss but neither party claimed that Hydrox was insolvent.

WDR and Lowes brought a claim to wind up Hydrox pursuant to s 233(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), on the sole ground that the affairs of Hydrox have been conducted in a manner “oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to or unfairly discriminatory” against WDR, as set out in s 232(e) of the Corporations Act. WDR alleged there were deficiencies in the provision of information to Lowes’ nominated directors and wrongful voting by Woolworths’ nominated directors, among other claims. Woolworths preferred for the matter to be resolved by arbitration rather than litigation in the courts. Woolworths invoked s 7(2)(b) of the International Arbitration Act, which requires the court to refer to arbitration matters that are capable of settlement by arbitration.

Issue

Did the Court proceeding involve the determination of matters capable of settlement by arbitration?

Judgment

The Federal Court of Australia referred the substantive controversy between the parties to arbitration, whilst the question of whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a winding up order is subsequently determined by the Court.

Public Interest

A matter might not be arbitrable if there are public interest considerations. Justice Foster held there was no substantial public interest element in this case because it was a dispute involving the only two shareholders in Hydrox and the only parties to the joint venture agreement, and the plaintiffs did not claim that Hydrox should be wound up in insolvency.

Winding Up & Third Party Rights

A winding up order may affect the rights of third parties, such as creditors and liquidators, and therefore it was argued that the winding up order has a sufficient element of public interest regardless of whether the winding up order is sought for insolvency or other purposes. Ultimately, Foster J held that the winding up process, except for the winding up order, were arbitrable, and stayed the winding up process until the matters were determined by arbitration.

Arbitration Prefacing Litigation

His Honour held that it would not be inappropriate for the substantive controversy to be the subject of determination by arbitration. The court can decide whether the matters warranted a winding up order whilst having regard to the preordained arbitral award.

Key Takeaways

  1. Australian courts do not shy away from referring matters to arbitration when the parties involved have an arbitration agreement and the dispute concerns only the parties who have a material interest in the outcome.
  2. A winding up order sought by an applicant is not enough to warrant a dispute non-arbitrable.

Read Full Case – HERE 

By Josh Reisler

Josh is a second year law student at the University of Sydney and a part time intern at ADC. He completed his Bachelor of Commerce at McGill University in Canada and is interested in international commercial arbitration.

2019-09-21T11:34:08+10:00

Upcoming Events

  • Mediation Training - Adelaide
    • Days 1 - 3
      February 26, 2020 - February 28, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • Days 4 - 5
      March 2, 2020 - March 3, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

      Multidisciplinary Participation ADC’s mediation training is suitable for participants from a broad range of professions and sectors including: business; government; law; tertiary academics and…

  • Conflict Resolution & ADR - Adelaide
    • February 26, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Have you ever thought 'I could have managed that conflict situation better'? Or even better still, avoided it before it began! Conflict can occur in any contractual and personal…

  • Mediation Refresher Training - Adelaide
    • One day Mediation Refresher Training
      March 2, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • One day Mediation Refresher Training
      March 3, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    This one day programme is intended for candidates preparing for accreditation or re-accreditation, mediators seeking to complete their CPD requirements and those seeking an opportunity…

  • Mediation Accreditation Day - Adelaide
    • March 4, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Industry Approved Pathway to Australian National Mediation Accreditation Internationally approved by the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators 1-Day Accreditation Program ADC’s 5-day mediation course participants who…

  • Mediation Training - Sydney
    • Days 1 - 3
      March 4, 2020 - March 6, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • Days 4 - 5
      March 9, 2020 - March 10, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Your Mediation Training: choose the ADC difference How do you become a nationally accredited mediator, a more effective negotiator, a ‘mediation-skilled’ legal adviser, a more effective…

  • Conflict Resolution & ADR - Sydney
    • March 4, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Have you ever thought 'I could have managed that conflict situation better'? Or even better still, avoided it before it began! Conflict can occur in any contractual and personal…

  • Mediation Refresher Training - Sydney
    • One day Mediation Refresher Training
      March 9, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • One day Mediation Refresher Training
      March 10, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    This one day programme is intended for candidates preparing for accreditation or re-accreditation, mediators seeking to complete their CPD requirements and those seeking an opportunity…

  • Mediation Accreditation Day - Sydney
    • March 11, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Industry Approved Pathway to Australian National Mediation Accreditation Internationally approved by the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators 1-Day Accreditation Program ADC’s 5-day mediation course participants who…

  • Dispute Resolution and the Abrahamic Faiths
    • Commencing 5.45pm AEDT - State & Territory Time Zones Apply
      March 19, 2020
      5:45 pm - 7:00 pm
  • Mediating in the Headlights of Litigation and Arbitration
    • 1 Day - Commercial Mediation Masterclass & Networking Cocktail Party (Eligible for 8+ CPD Points)
      March 25, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • All 3 Days - Advanced Commercial Mediation Accreditation (Eligible for 25+ CPD Points)
      March 25, 2020 - March 27, 2020
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!