Food For Thought

Why mediators should use BATNAs carefully 

The concept of Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement, or BATNA, is immensely useful in meditation. A coined termed by Roger Fisher and William Ury in the widely publicised book ‘Getting to Yes’, BATNA is the most advantageous alternative course of action that a party can take if negotiations fail to reach an agreement. Mediators often ask BATNAs to better gauge each parties’ zone of agreement. This term is widely adopted and used by practitioners around the world.

In the recent paper by Jim Sebenius from the Harvard Business School “BATNAs in Negotiation: Common Errors and Three Kinds of ‘No’’, the author argues that utilising BATNA can be ‘problematic, limiting, and even misleading’ in three ways. Mediators should be cautious of using BATNAs too readily, as it may have unintended effects.

First, the author argues that BATNA, as the term suggests, hints that a result can be reached without considering a negotiation. Results can be obtained without negotiating as it is the best alternative to a negotiated agreement. Instead, BATNA should be construed so that parties have regard to the negotiation at hand, not just any negotiated agreement elsewhere.

Second, it is argued that BATNAs focuses the attention on what the party can achieve outside the current negotiation. It does not take into account of the other parties’ needs, wants, or perspectives. While parties are encouraged to use BATNAs and thus consider their options independently of other parties, in reality negotiating parties interact. As such, instead of utilising BATNA in terms of ‘outside options’ that are ‘independent’, a different question to invoke should be: ‘What are the full consequences of saying ‘no’ to the other sides’ proposal?’

Third, conceptualizing BATNA as a last resort can be unnecessarily limiting. BATNA is supposed to be a fall-back alternative in the event that parties fail to reach an agreement. BATNAs should not be utilised as a last resort (unless during a situation that Fisher and Ury referred to where there is an asymmetrical power where one party is more ‘powerful’ than another) but rather a preparation tool to assess holistically each parties’ interests and possibility of an agreement. BATNAs should be used as a vehicle for creative possible solutions, not as one which limits parties.

 

Further reading and reference:

Sebenius, James K., BATNAs in Negotiation: Common Errors and Three Kinds of ‘No’ (January 28, 2017). Negotiation Journal, Forthcoming; Harvard Business School NOM Unit Working Paper No. 17-055. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2884857 

Compiled by: Cindy Wong, Dispute Resolution Associate at ADC

2019-09-21T11:34:08+11:00

Upcoming Events

  • Mediation Training - Hobart
    • Days 1 - 3
      November 20, 2019 - November 22, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • Days 4 - 5
      November 25, 2019 - November 26, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    About the ADC Mediation Course An ADR industry leader, ADC has been at the forefront of providing mediation training courses since 1986. Recognised nationally and…

  • Conflict Resolution & ADR - Hobart
    • November 20, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Ever wished you could manage conflict better? Better still, even avoid it before it begins? Conflict happens in all organisations and communities. Discover how to minimise…

  • Beyond Googlies & Cricket: India and Australia Trade, Investment, and Successful Dispute Resolution
    • Commencing 4.15pm AEDT - Australian and Indian Times Zones Apply
      November 20, 2019
      4:00 pm - 5:15 pm

    City Hosts Register below for your city Brisbane At 4:15pm AEST Level Twenty Seven Chambers Level 27, 239 George St, Brisbane Sydney (Now at HWL)…

  • Mediation Refresher Training - Hobart
    • One day Mediation Refresher Training
      November 25, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • One day Mediation Refresher Training
      November 26, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    This one day programme is intended for candidates preparing for accreditation or re-accreditation, mediators seeking to complete their CPD requirements and those seeking an opportunity…

  • Mediation Training - Sydney
    • Days 1 - 3
      November 27, 2019 - November 29, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • Days 4 - 5
      December 2, 2019 - December 3, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    About the ADC Mediation Course An ADR industry leader, ADC has been at the forefront of providing mediation training courses since 1986. Recognised nationally and…

  • Mediation Accreditation Day - Hobart
    • November 27, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Mediation course participants seeking formal recognition of their skills are eligible to enrol in ADC’s accreditation program. ADC’s Mediation Training meets the requirements set out…

  • Conflict Resolution & ADR - Sydney
    • November 27, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Ever wished you could manage conflict better? Better still, even avoid it before it begins? Conflict happens in all organisations and communities. Discover how to minimise…

  • Mediation Refresher Training - Sydney
    • One day Mediation Refresher Training
      December 2, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • One day Mediation Refresher Training
      December 3, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    This one day programme is intended for candidates preparing for accreditation or re-accreditation, mediators seeking to complete their CPD requirements and those seeking an opportunity…

  • Mediation Accreditation Day - Sydney
    • December 4, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Mediation course participants seeking formal recognition of their skills are eligible to enrol in ADC’s accreditation program. ADC’s Mediation Training meets the requirements set out…

  • Mediation Training - Melbourne
    • Days 1 - 3
      December 11, 2019 - December 13, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm
    • Days 4 - 5
      December 16, 2019 - December 17, 2019
      8:30 am - 5:00 pm

      About the ADC Mediation Course An ADR industry leader, ADC has been at the forefront of providing mediation training courses since 1986. Recognised nationally…

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!